When it comes to keeping your furry friend safe, a reliable pet ID tag is one of the simplest yet most effective tools you can have. But not all pet tags are created equal. One of the most common questions pet owners ask is: “Should I choose an engraved or printed pet tag?”
Both types serve the same basic purpose — to display your pet’s identification details — but how they are made and how well they last can vary significantly. In this guide, we’ll take a deep dive into the pros and cons of engraved vs. printed pet tags, and help you decide which is best for your dog or cat.
Why a Quality Pet ID Tag Matters
Before diving into the differences, let’s talk about why the quality of a pet tag matters.
According to the Australian Animal Welfare Strategy, 1 in 3 pets will go missing at some point in their lives. The good news? A clearly labelled pet tag dramatically increases the chances of a speedy reunion. But if the writing on your tag fades, chips, or becomes illegible over time, it’s as good as no tag at all.
That’s why choosing between engraved and printed pet tags isn't just about looks — it’s about longevity, durability, and safety.
Engraved Pet Tags: Classic, Durable, Reliable
Engraved pet tags have been the gold standard for decades — and for good reason.
✅ Pros of Engraved Tags:
1. Long-Lasting Text
The text is physically carved into the metal or material, making it very hard to wear off. Even if the tag gets scratched or wet, the information remains readable.
2. Resistant to Weather and Wear
High-quality engraved tags, especially those made from stainless steel or aluminium, can withstand Australia’s outdoor elements — from coastal humidity to desert heat.
3. Classic Appearance
Engraving gives the tag a neat and professional look. Whether you prefer bone-shaped tags or stylish designer options, engraving adds a touch of class.
4. Easy to Customise
Most engraved tags allow for multiple lines of text, so you can include your pet’s name, your phone number, address, and even medical needs.
❌ Cons of Engraved Tags:
-
Less colourful than printed tags (although some come with colour-coated surfaces).
-
If not done properly, shallow engraving can still fade — which is why it’s important to choose a reputable provider.
Pro Tip: At Pet ID Tags Australia, we offer deep-engraved stainless steel and anodised aluminium tags designed to last for years — with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Printed Pet Tags: Stylish but Short-Lived?
Printed tags are a more recent option and can be very appealing at first glance — especially for pet owners who want a bright, colourful, or fun design.
✅ Pros of Printed Tags:
1. Vibrant Designs
Printed tags can feature patterns, photos, graphics, and logos. Great if you want your pet to stand out at the dog park.
2. Lightweight Materials
Many printed tags are made from lightweight plastic or acrylic, which can be more comfortable for small dogs or cats.
3. Inexpensive
In general, printed tags may be cheaper upfront compared to engraved metal ones.
❌ Cons of Printed Tags:
1. Text Fades Over Time
Printed ink or dye can fade or scratch off, especially if your pet is active or wears their collar 24/7.
2. Less Durable
Plastic or acrylic tags are more prone to breaking or cracking, especially if chewed or stepped on.
3. Weather Vulnerability
Printed tags can degrade faster when exposed to sunlight, rain, or salt water, making them a poor choice for outdoor pets.
Engraved vs. Printed: Which Is Better?
| Feature | Engraved Tags | Printed Tags |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | ✅ Excellent (especially stainless steel) | ❌ Moderate to low |
| Readability | ✅ Long-lasting | ❌ Can fade or scratch off |
| Design Options | ✅ Classic, minimal | ✅ Colourful, fun |
| Weather Resistance | ✅ High | ❌ Low to moderate |
| Best for Active Pets | ✅ Yes | ❌ Not recommended |
| Lifespan | ✅ Years | ❌ Often months |
What Do Australian Pet Owners Prefer?
Based on feedback from thousands of customers across Australia, engraved tags are by far the more reliable and trusted option. While printed tags may be fun for special occasions or photo shoots, most pet owners turn to engraved metal tags for everyday wear.
Especially in Australia’s variable climate — from rainy Melbourne to dry Alice Springs — durability is key. You want your pet’s ID tag to last as long as possible, no matter where they roam.
Best Materials for Engraved Pet Tags
Not all engraved tags are equal. The material matters just as much as the engraving method. Here are the top options:
🥇 Stainless Steel
-
Rust-proof
-
Scratch-resistant
-
Longest-lasting option
-
Available in polished or brushed finishes
🥈 Anodised Aluminium
-
Lightweight
-
Comes in bright colours
-
Resistant to corrosion (when anodised properly)
🥉 Brass
-
Classic gold appearance
-
Slightly softer, so may show scratches over time
Avoid uncoated aluminium or thin plastic tags if you're after durability.
What Should You Engrave on Your Pet’s Tag?
Once you’ve chosen your tag, make sure to include the right information. For Australian pets, we recommend:
-
🐾 Pet’s Name
-
📱 Phone Number (Mobile preferred)
-
📍 Suburb or Postcode
-
💊 Medical Alert (if needed)
-
💬 Reward Message (e.g. “Reward if found”)
Need help deciding what to engrave? Check out our full guide: What to Put on a Dog ID Tag in Australia
Final Verdict: Engraved Wins for Everyday Use
If you want a tag that stands the test of time, keeps your pet safe, and doesn’t need to be replaced every few months, engraved tags are the way to go.
At Pet ID Tags Australia, we offer a wide range of deeply engraved stainless steel and anodised aluminium tags in all shapes and sizes — backed by fast shipping, excellent customer support, and our 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Shop Durable Engraved Pet Tags Today
Whether you have a playful pup, a curious cat, or a senior dog who needs a medical alert tag, we’ve got options to suit every pet and personality.
👉 Ready to shop? Explore our Dog Tags Australia collection
